Endorsement and recommendation

I get a lot of requests for letters of recommendation and arXiv endorsements. I’ll happily consider providing either, but I have a few requirements.

Please email me here, but only after reading this first.

Back home

arXiv endorsements

An arXiv endorsement is what it sounds like. When I endorse you, I’m lending my own credibility to vouch for you and your work. Submissions to arXiv are climbing at an unsustainable rate, with a lot of what’s being submitted almost certainly written by AI.

If you’d like to ask me for an endorsement, first send me:

  1. A final draft of the manuscript you plan to upload.
  2. Screenshots from Pangram showing that, at minimum, the abstract, results, and discussion/conclusions sections are 100% human written.

Letters of recommendation

If I’ve worked with you in any professional capacity and you need a letter of recommendation for things like an application to grad school or a job application, I will happily consider providing one. I am only able to write letters for people I have worked with directly and can vouch for personally.

I have a similar requirement for letters of recommendation as I do for arXiv endorsements: I’m only willing to lend my credibility to vouch for people who can demonstrate that their application materials are human written. If you’re asking for a letter of recommendation, please send me:

  1. A brief description of the position or program you’re applying to, and why you think I would be a good person to write a letter for you.
  2. Any other logistical information (deadlines, submission instructions, etc.) that I need to know to write and submit the letter.
  3. A final draft of your application materials (personal statement, CV, etc.).
  4. Screenshots from Pangram showing that, at minimum, your personal statement, cover letter, research statement, or other narratives are 100% human written.

FAQ

What about my intellectual property?

If you’re publishing a manuscript to a preprint server, it’ll be consumed and trained on by AI anyway. For job or grad school applications, it’s unlikely that your cover letter or research statement will contain any truly sensitive IP. If this is a real concern, let’s talk.

Don’t these AI detectors like Pangram make mistakes?

No, not really. Maybe they did in the past, but update your priors. Personal experience and empirical data show that misclassifications are rare.

But don’t you use AI?

I do, but I try to do so judiciously when it comes to writing. If I use AI to help write a paper, I know the lengths I personally go to in order to ensure the product faithfully represents work I’ve done and conclusions I believe in. For AI-generated text produced by anyone other than me, I can’t know the degree to which its author understands the content or contributed to its creation.

Isn’t this all a little heavy-handed?

Maybe so. But if I’m going to stake my credibility on someone else’s work, I want to be sure that work is their own, not something generated by AI where I have no indication of the author’s involvement.

Back home